OK then, here's a post to collect the various words of praise (or even damnation, we're not fussy) about the book they're all calling 'Eh? Oh, that thing.' Admittedly not a lot going on as yet, but we're told it's still 'early days' and things will 'bottom out in the fullness of time'. We think that's the phrase they used, anyway.
Radio Times film editor Andrew Collins reckons -
'A book where constant amnesty reigns and no film dares not speak its name. How could you not love a book that includes the words, "Lew Grade: dancer for money", reminds us that Madeline Smith did a degree, holds Michael Ripper up for long-overdue reassessment and claims that Tony Hancock's Punch And Judy Man may have influenced Jaws?'
Over here, Ed Holden, the editor of MSN Movies UK calls us 'hilarious' and, rather gratifyingly, picks up on the 'Essential Secret Lair' article which we'd previously thought was one of the bits of the book which fell into the category of 'Nice idea, didn't quite work.' So, result!
Here's a blogging fellow who reckons us 'well worth reading if you're into films'. The mercenary within us notes he also seems to be a professional bookbuyer...
While over on Amazon, Miche Doherty muses -
'From a list of British silents of which nothing remains but evocative titles, such as Too Much Sausage and Two Naughty Boys Upsetting The Spoons, to a handy chart for the identification of UK independents (if a period drama looks like an Athena poster it's a Goldcrest; if it doesn't it's either a Gaumont-British or a Gainsborough, depending on the emphasis on heaving bosoms), this is a great dipper-in of a book celebrating some of the more unsung actors, film-makers and genres. The proof-reader nodded off from time to time (Wilfred Bramble, indeed!), but if any or all of the following names - Milton Subotsky, Marianne Stone, Frank Randle - ring bells for you, you'll find lots to enjoy.'
Yes, that 'Bramble' was the first thing we noticed on getting a copy of the book, and we swear it was at some point corrected, but there you go. We'll add to this list when more critical reaction comes our way. In the meantime, feel free to append your praise, opprobrium and minor niggles (but no more typo remarks, please, we've spotted them all - 'Nicholas Roeg' etc.) below. Ta!